Brooklyn Pizzeria in Spring Lake

We absolutely love Brooklyn Pizza! The pizza, manicotti, and Stromboli is consistently amazing. It’s a great family run establishment.

Can't go wrong with the food here. Everything is good. Customer service is great.

Best a Pizza Around! Nicest people you’ve ever met that have been there forever! 100% Consistent!!

The cannolis are top notch and that's what really sells this place for me.

Best freaking pizza in the area. Everything I bought from there was amazing, from the fried mac n cheese bites to the wings. Their food is worth EVERY CENT!

Can't beat this pizza. Had it for lunch, dinner, and lunch again today. When in town this is the place to eat.

Crispy crust just how I love it

By far the best pizza I’ve had in the area... don’t let the look of the plaza steer you away, pizza is real good!

Probably the best pizza I've had down here in NC. Coming from NY and hearing Brooklyn Pizza I was skeptical. As soon as I walked in I knew I was home. It had the smell of great pizza. The guy behind the counter threw up a pie that looked like it was half the size of my daughter. My mouth started to water and i couldn't wait for a large extra pepperoni pie. We had three medium fountain drinks for here. It had all the delicious grease that a pie should have. The three of us eat it and enjoyed everything offered. We left satisfied and still had two slices left over. I will definitely be going there for now one. Thank you Brooklyn crew for the good service and great food. You made my wife's day.

Best pizza in North Carolina. Great service. The most friendly staff

The place is so homey, and the people are so nice! The slices are huge and have amazing flavor. I’d spend the last $2.50 to my name for a slice🤣

Great service, great pizza!

BEST PIZZA EVER. I absolutely loved this pizza. I’m italian and I’m so picky about pizza. I’ve tried so many pizzas since I’ve been to the States (chain pizzas, pizzas from “Italian restaurants” etc) BUT, BOY Brooklyn pizzeria beats them all! This is close to style I’m used to and it’s so worth the price. I had a great experience. I can’t wait to come back!!! I don’t know who made the pizza today, but THANK YOU! I hope you’ll be there next time too!!!

Service with a smile! That’s not something you find everyday. The pizza was thin and crispy, the sauce was bright and delicious and the cheese was beautifully salty. Honestly a delicious slice of pizza all around. Definitely recommend! The pizza is much larger than your average slice or pie FYI.

Family atmosphere. Reasonably priced. Very nice and helpful staff.

Excellent pizza! The portions are very generous. The service was good. The restuarant was empty at the time I went, but it seemed like it would be a fun environment when with a group.

Been eating at this place for over 20 years. You don't do that when something isn't good.

Wow amazing and original taste. Everything taste fresh and the staff takes their time perfecting every pizza.

Best pizza in the state, in my opinion.

I never been to Brooklyn so I have to take this places word for it. I love thin giant pizzas. Like I have to fold the pizza slice 10 times to hold it big. Nice people up front. You can tell they’re stressed, and I would be too standing next to a hot oven dealing with people who act like they never ordered or heard of pizza before while they’re ordering.

The best hand tossed any way you want it pizza. When it come out of the oven before you bite in! Let it cool a little or blow on your slice,lol,HOT!.

Pizza was decent , not bad for NC. But the wings were terrible !! Very very very small & had no taste. Im from Jersey so I think my expectations are too high for here..lol.

Best place for pizza in North Carolina, I have been going here since I was a little kid and it’s just as amazing. The staff is always super nice. And the pizzas are amazing

Great prices & very friendly. Been going here for over 10 years.

Great pizza that doesnt taste like store bought frozen food!

One of the best New York style pizza in the area.

Best pizza you can find in north Carolina state it tastes just like puzza from new york city soooo 5 stars for this place definently

Went there yesterday and had 2 slices of pepperoni to-go and man that was the best pizza ever ! Thanks guys really great restaurant. Looking forward to eating there again . -Josh A.

Love this place. I recommend it to everyone.

Most excellent steak and cheese sub 😋

Came for a quick bite and it’s hands down the best pizza I had in a long time! Very delicious! Would recommend to friends and family

This is the best Brooklyn Pizza in the surrounding areas... They have the BEST NY Style Pizza around! Hands Down!

I have been going there for 20 yrs. It was as good today as the first time. I drive an hour to get there and it's always worth the drive.

I absolutely love this place. Best pizza around

Best pizza in town! I can't speak for the other items on the menu.Quick and friendly service.

This is exactly the pizza joint I look for. The service is great, the price is more than fair, and the restaurant feels like an early 90's relic. Slices are bigger than your head and taste just like a pop-in pizza spot in Manhattan. 5/5 would recommend.

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. We ordered a large and it was HUGE! It was delicious and pretty cheap (less than $20 for 8 huge slices). Staff was friendly. The only knock is that the dining area is a bit dated and it truely is a 'hole-in-the-wall' place, but once you taste the pizza, you forget where you are! Highly recommended!

Really cool little pizzeria. they make perfect New York pizzas with the thin toasty crust and the big slices... really good. that was a perfect lunch. Cheers guys 🍻

Came all the way from Charlotte for business and got hungry. Came to check out why this pizza has such good reviews and was not disappointed. Pizza was one of the best I tried in States!!

The Pizza is about a 3-4 out of five. We ordered a pepperoni extra cheese and wings. Please take the wings off the menu!! They look like this. I took one bite and threw that one and the next 11 in the trash. They are the worst wings I have ever had. Very soggy texture and not much flavor.

Best tasting pizza in town and very affordable.

Great place to get pizza. Been coming here with my grandpa for many years. Great staff and the pizza is always fresh.

Unable to get the order right. Last time I go there

BEST NY style Pizza in the area!! I am from Jersey...long way from home & when I want my NY style Pizza.... Brooklyn Pizzeria is the ONLY place for me...got a large family... we order about twice a month... the household LOVES it!!

I ordered everything special pizza with extra cheese.. the pizza was good size for being a Large, they were generous with toppings and it tasted good... reason for 2 stars was price and mostly the soggy crust which made pizza collapse..I had to eat with fork...I couldn’t just pick up slice and bite into it.. the bread was literally soggy wet... mushy... for $25 it could have been better...

Best pizza in NC. Have been coming here for 20yrs. Pizza is just like pizza in NY. I am originally from Jersey and always eat pizza here to remind me of what good pizza tastes like.

This pizza was DISGUSTING! So much grease and it made the pizza taste so salty... I couldn’t eat it I ate one piece and I regret it because my stomach hurts now and I have the nastiest taste in my mouth. It was so thin too I know it’s thin pizza but jeez am I just eating cheese and grease ??? I’m so disgusted right now. I will not be coming again nor my husband. I can’t believe we wasted 16$ For something so mediocre. Also, we came back after waiting 25 minutes and the pizza was done but they didn’t even let us know until I went up and asked is the pizza done and they turned around and said yes so that’s great. Also, the place was so hot! Poor employees and customers who want to dine inn. Wish I could get my money back.

Don’t be put off by the nondescript outside appearance of this place - the pizzas are excellent, the salads are fresh, and the garlic knots are positively addictive! Plus the staff is friendly and the prices are reasonable. A new favorite place!

The pizza is good and the employees are friendly. The ravioli was really good. They the garlic knots, too.

This is my favorite pizza in the area. My husband and I ordered the x large pizza and it was so big, we needed two paper plates together for one piece. That was awesome! It was cheesy, perfect amount of sauce. It is a little greasy but I like it like that. We brought home leftovers, and they were good the next day.